Skip to Content

Heirloom Tomatoes

heirloom tomatoes

January in the Midwest has few redeeming values, in my mind, other than it signals garden planning. Throughout the month, I grumpily turn my back on my snow-filled yard and reach for my gardening notebook. I review my previous growing season’s notes, and decide what I’ll grow again this year, as well as what new goodies I’ll add to the mix from the new seed catalogs.

My favorite crop, first and foremost, is the tomato crop, and I linger over this list longer than necessary. I [heart] heirloom tomatoes. I love their variety. I love their colors, their crazy shapes. But most of all, I love their flavors. There’s no hybrid that can match an heirloom. Heirloom tomato and mozzarella salad with basil? Yes, please.

The Heirloom Tomatoes

Here are some notes about the varieties I grew in 2009. (I buy my tomato seeds from, in case you’re interested.) It was a great tomato year. All plants produced, and took their time succumbing to the inevitable wilt that plagues heirloom tomatoes. Which made SoupAddict very happy.

Amish Paste

heirloom tomatoes amish paste

A very nice roma tomato, Amish Paste was beautiful on the vine, delicious in both sauces and salads. I have nothing bad to say about this tomato, but for 2010, I’ll be going back to the Long Tom variety I grew in 2008. Just a personal preference.

Black Cherry

heirloom tomatoes black cherry

Probably my all-around favorite tomato. I’m a huge fan of the purple/black family of tomatoes, with their complex, smokey flavors. The Black Cherry is a lot of tomato goodness in a small package. About the size of a quarter, these tomatoes are blemish-free with a gorgeous deep red color inside and out, topped off with green shoulders. Like most heirlooms, this plant is prone to wilt diseases, but somehow still manages to keep producing well into the end of the growing season.

Black Krim

heirloom tomatoes black krim

This photo (and the photo of the Flamme below) cracks me up. I took this early in the season, when I had delusions of grand tomato photography for 2009. At this point, I had a total of two ripe tomatoes, and nothing else (save a few stray radishes from the Spring crop). Then August hit full force and there was barely time for even the minimal record-keeping photography (which you see on this page), much less elaborate tomato voguing. The Black Krim is awfully pretty, though. And mighty, mighty tasty – one of the best of the black tomatoes


heirloom tomatoes brandywine

There’s a reason why Brandywine has such an exulted reputation: It’s perfection on a branch. If it has any flaws at all, it’s that it’s a fairly low producer. Or maybe I’m simply Brandywine-greedy.


heirloom tomatoes dona

Ah, Dona, Dona, Dona. The tomato of my youth. My much-older brothers grew heirloom tomatoes at our parents’. They were in college; I was in junior high. I have a distinct memory of devouring an English muffin slathered with mayo, a slice of cheese, and many, many slices of a Dona tomato. The tomato gets a thumbs-up, but the plant did not do very well, due to my stubborn unwillingness to accept that my tomato plants grow 15 feet tall by 6 feet wide. Dona ended up crammed in a corner, fighting for elbow room. Poor Dona, she deserved better.


heirloom tomatoes flamme

I adore this tomato. Behaving like a cherry, this plant keeps on going and going and going, producing lovely heart-shaped, bright orange fruit right through October. And the flavor is just scrumptious. Acidic like a red tomato, but slightly more fruity, providing a wonderful counterbalance in tomato salads.

heirloom tomatoes flamme

Flamme produced its first mature tomato just before the Black Krim (above) and was a participant in the Grand Delusion photography experiment. I have this picture framed, by the way, because I love tomatoes and I’m weird like that.


heirloom tomatoes limony

If you’re a fan of the mild yellow tomato, this one’s for you. Producing lovely, medium-sized, perfectly tomato-shaped tomatoes, Limony was a pleasant surprise, even though it had several things going against it. First, the seed sprouted late, and I decided only at the last minute to keep it. Second, I planted it in my plot at the local community garden, which is only two years old and therefore does not have the benefit of the über-rich soil in my own gardens.

Matt’s Wild Cherry

heirloom tomatoes matts wild cherry

Meet the world’s most aptly named tomato. See this plant, people? This photo was not taken in September. This photo was not taken in October. No, people. This photo was taken in August. Early August. See that gutter on the left? That’s 15 feet up (see how it dwarfs the air conditioning unit?). I literally couldn’t take a picture of the plant later in the season because I lacked a wide angle lens (and the gumption to splice two pictures together). By the time I tore the plant down, that window was completely obscured by branches reaching nearly the second level roof.

heirloom tomatoes matts wild cherry

However, if you have the proper equipment to allow the plant to trail, controlled, over a low trellis or across the ground, it does produce some wonderfully flavored little tomatoes. I’d always wander back to that plant while gardening, just to pluck some jewels right off the vine and pop ’em in my mouth. They were always perfect, unblemished, and uncracked.

Orange Strawberry

heirloom tomatoes orange strawberry

This was one interesting experiment. The pictures of this tomato were so pretty on, about twice the size of a strawberry and a gentle shade of yellow-orange. The plant, however, took off like a shot once in the ground. As promised the young tomatoes were a pretty strawberry shape and looked so elegant hanging on the vine. But then, something kicked in and they grew. And grew. And grew. And grew. The tomato pictured here was almost a pound-and-a-half. It filled my entire palm.

This was all well and good, but the plant wasn’t really bred to support one-pound tomatoes. Even though I staked the plant with metal cages and wooden supports, the weight of the plant soon bent it in half, splintering the wooden stakes. The lesson here is that if you obsess over the state of your soil (as I do), the plants are going to love it, so be prepared to take byzantine measures to support the plants. (And I do, having a caging and support plan that can easily accommodate 15 foot plants). You’ll have to trust me when I say that this plant was a monster.

Like most yellow tomatoes, the flavor of the Orange Strawberry is mild and sweet. Before cutting down the plant, I pulled the green tomatoes, and wow, did they make awesome fried green tomatoes (especially fried green tomato BLTs – the tomatoes were so huge that one slice filled the sandwich).

All of these varieties made the “will grow again” list, but the keepers for 2010 are the Black Cherry, Black Krim, Brandywine, and Flamme. And back from 2008’s crop will be Aunt Ginny’s Purple and Long Tom. I can’t wait!

Subscribe to the SoupAddict Weekly Digest and get new soups and other delish foods in bowls in your inbox!

Thank You For Subscribing!

So glad to have you aboard, fellow Soup Lover! Stay tuned for the first edition!


Saturday 22nd of October 2011

I just found your website. Please tell me, what do you ad to your soil to make it so prolific??? I live in Alabama and we have a lot of clay here. What's your secret??? Dave


Saturday 22nd of October 2011

Hi Dave,

Clay is a toughie. I do soil amendments both Spring and Fall. In the fall, I add all the compost that's been brewing all summer long, plus bags of purchased mushroom or cow manure compost. And then top everything off with a thick layer of well-chopped leaves and mulched grass. And then everything gets turned in to the existing soil by hand. In the Spring, I add bags of compost and mulched grass, and turn it all in about 4 weeks before planting. I also use a home soil testing kit to check for imbalances, and add lime or bone meal as needed to correct pH levels. One of these years, I'm going to grow a cover crop in the winter, and turn that in in the Spring. Just haven't gotten around to buying the seeds. :) Hope that helps, and good luck!

Tom White

Friday 11th of March 2011

I took two cues from your list hear and am planting Black Cherry and Orange Strawberry this year. They looks so nice.


Friday 11th of March 2011

Yeah, sure, blame your typing. I'll go with that.

You got me completely addicted to the black tomatoes: this might be the year I do an all-black tomato garden (except for Brandywine). Even the sauces I canned and froze for the winter, the black tomato-based ones were the best. You're really going to like the Black Cherry. It can be a little slow on the uptake, but it's always the last tomato to stop producing (actually, I should say, it never stops producing - *I* cause it to stop producing by tearing it down).

I don't know what was up with that Orange Strawberry - for a while it was staked up on one side by a two-by-four, which unceremoniously splintered in half under its weight. I have pictures somewhere.

Tom White

Friday 11th of March 2011

"HERE"! Ugh... typing.

Mommas Soapbox

Monday 1st of February 2010

Love this post! I am planning my garden, which includes much tall fencing to keep the deer out......had no idea there were so many tomatoes to choose from...... Some really pretty ones.

OH and I LOVE LOVE LOVE basil, mozzarella cheese and tomatoe salad. My fav!

Now I'm hungry!


Sunday 31st of January 2010

The Orange Strawberry would definitely behave better in a pot. I had also grown a second Orange Strawberry plant in the nutrient-lite-soil of the community garden I mentioned, and the fruit were much more in line with the description from It's a very pretty tomato. I do wish you luck, and a successful 2010 gardening season!


Saturday 30th of January 2010

All of my tomatoes are grown in pots. In Florida the ground is sand, sand and more sand. Until you reach clay. I have grown Brandywine in the past and they are wonderful, but I never got the huge crop I wanted. I will be checking over your list again and trying some of the cherries and maybe Donna or Orange Strawberry. This year I am also going to try putting my pots in the back yard, hoping that they will be happier there. Wish me luck.