<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://ct.pinterest.com/v3/?event=init&tid=2612641878717&pd[em]=&noscript=1" /> Skip to Content

Tomato Lover’s Tomato Salad with Smoky Tomato Dressing

We’re nearly to the peak of tomato season, and if you’re enjoying daily tomato salads, you’re doing summer eating right! My tomato lover’s tomato salad is piled high with summer’s best heirloom tomatoes and drizzled with a to-die-for smoky tomato dressing.

Tomato salad in a big white bowl

Hi, tomato-lovin’ fans! I may or may not have lured you here under false pretenses. Or, slightly false pretenses.

Because the truth is, while this tomato salad is the bomb, you really can’t go wrong anytime you wedge up a summer tomato and fork it into your mouth, one delectable chunk at a time.

Flavor goodness, guaranteed, with those juicy-fresh summer tomatoes.

What I really wanted to share today is the dressing that goes with this salad. Yup, I’m one of those people, who likes to make their own salad dressings. You might not have noticed haha but next to soup, a good salad is one of my very favorite things on this earthly spinning orb, and the last thing I want to do to undermine all the healthy, crunchy bennies of a veggie-loaded salad is to pour some crazy oil- and sugar-loaded goop all over it.

Smoky Tomato Salad Dressing in a small glass bottle

But, I get it. I get you. Time is short, and not everyone wants to spend 5 minutes whipping up something they can pull out of the fridge in 10 seconds and be done with it.

So, it has to be worth your time, right? It has to be pretty speshul. And friends, this dressing is both.

With a base of fresh summer tomatoes, tangy white balsamic, and the perfect pinch of smoky paprika, this dressing has unexpected hints of BLT flavorings that will drive you right over the edge of obsession. Lip-smacking BLT tastiness in a vegetarian package. Good and good for you!

Close-up of smoky tomato dressing

So when you take a simple salad with the summer’s best tomatoes, plus crispy cucumbers, fresh herbs, and a light portion of feta cheese, and you pour a smoky, tangy dressing over the top, you’ve got one amazing salad! (Or, for us tomato salad lovers, a meal!)

I specifically crafted the tomato dressing for my tomato lover’s tomato salad to use very little oil, because I wanted the freedom to douse all of my summer salads in pools of this smoky tomato brilliance, without guilt, without worry about the healthfulness of such a drenching.

Because here’s the thing about oils: we’ve been culturally conditioned to love our oils — coconut, olive, canola, avocado — and you can’t browse the interwebs without stubbing your toe on some study that touts the health benefits of this oil or that oil. But, the truth is, oils are loaded with calorie-heavy fats. Empty calories, at that. Whether you buy into the story of medium-chain triglycerides (coconut oil) or monounsaturated fatty acids (olive oil) as sources of health and vitality, either way, you’re still consuming extra fat and calories: a tablespoon of each has about 120 calories – all of it from fat. Have you ever measured out a true tablespoon of salad dressing? It’s pitifully skimpy, when added to a bowlful of salad.

Close-up of bowl of tomato lovers salad

If your family history of heart disease looks like mine — a dense, multi-branched tree of relatives on all sides, etched with clogged arteries, strokes, and early deaths — fat is more foe than friend. The human body does, indeed, need polyunsaturated fats (such as omega-3 fatty acids) to maintain good health, but consumption beyond what is necessary flirts needlessly with artery-lining cholesterol and waist-lining fat.

Personally, I use only extra virgin olive oil these days, but very sparingly in recipes where it does not need to play a starring role. And when I make this dressing just for myself — because, hello, personal dressing stash — I don’t use oil at all.

And in typing that sentence, I just realized that I do, indeed, have a personal stash of salad dressings in my refrigerator. Lol. When did I become that person?

Tomato Lover's Tomato Salad in a big white bowl with a side of smoky tomato dressing

Tomato beauty is skin deep

I hope you’ll also indulge me a sec while I veer off on a little tomato prep soapbox. I’ve seen one too many recipes this summer that call for peeling tomatoes, or — major eyeroll — running them through a food mill.

Now, I don’t mean y’all can’t peel your tomatoes for your world famous salsa — although, the thought of that still makes me a little sad. But I hear ya: texture issues.

However, when you’re blending tomatoes for soup or sauce … or this dressing … please, just don’t. Especially if you’re using the season’s most beautiful and flavor-loaded heirloom tomatoes. Respect the whole tomato — the skin, the seeds, the gel sac surrounding the seeds — and use every last bit of it. A tomato’s nutrition and tangy flavors are in the skin and the seeds/gel, and by milling it all out, well, you might as well just use a pale, bland grocery store tomato, and get it over with. No heirloom tomato should be sent through a food mill.

If your blender leaves behind unacceptable residues of skins and seeds, I would argue that you need to invest in a better blender (for all-around cooking, not just tomato recipes), not in a space-hogging food mill that has limited use — sell the food mill and upgrade your blender! (I owned a food mill that saw the light of day for a total of about five minutes, when a fancy food magazine convinced a much younger and less knowledgeable me that I wasn’t a serious cook until I had one. It felt really, really good to finally get rid of that thing. That, and the pretentious food magazine.)

I don’t own one of those awesome high-speed mega blenders myself (I just envy them on Amazon), so I use my handy-dandy little NutriBullet blender, which I use almost everyday to create beautiful dressings and sauces and smoothies with just a teensy bit of clean-up. I’ve never had problems with unblended bits of tomato — look how smooth that dressing is above!

A forkful of tomato lover's tomato salad

Oh, this bowl of fresh tomatoes, people! If there was one thing I wish we could preserve for the winter, it would be fresh, whole, homegrown rainbow cherry tomatoes, ready for salads and random snacking. Summer is winding down fast (whut!), so enjoy your tomato lover’s tomato salad while you can!

Karen xo

Tomato Lover's Tomato Salad | Recipe at SoupAddict.com
Print Recipe
5 from 4 votes

Tomato Lover's Tomato Salad

This tomato lover's tomato salad is piled high with summer's best heirloom tomatoes and drizzled with a to-die-for smoky tomato dressing that tastes like a BLT.
Prep Time15 minutes
Total Time15 minutes
Servings: 4
Calories: 38kcal
Author: Karen Gibson


  • 24 cherry tomatoes , quartered
  • 1 pickling cucumber , chopped or sliced thinly lengthwise and rolled into curls
  • 1 ounce reduced fat feta cheese , crumbled
  • 2 teaspoons chopped fresh dill
  • 1 heaping tablespoon fresh basil sliced chiffonade (4 to 5 leaves)
  • 2 tablespoons Smoky Tomato Dressing (below)


  • Combine the tomatoes and cucumbers in a large bowl. Top with the feta cheese and herbs, and toss lightly. Drizzle with Smoky Tomato Dressing.


Calories: 38kcal
Nutritional information, if shown, is provided as a courtesy only, and is not to be taken as medical information or advice. The nutritional values of your preparation of this recipe are impacted by several factors, including, but not limited to, the ingredient brands you use, any substitutions or measurement changes you make, and measuring accuracy.

Smoky Tomato Dressing | Recipe at SoupAddict.com
Print Recipe
5 from 4 votes

Smoky Tomato Dressing

A savory dressing that perfect's for all of your summer salads - but especially heirloom tomato salads - that has irresistible hints of BLT flavorings.
Prep Time10 minutes
Total Time10 minutes
Servings: 8
Calories: 31kcal
Author: Karen Gibson


  • 1 heaping cup roughly chopped fresh tomatoes , shallowly cored (4 small, 2 medium, or 14 or cherry)
  • 2 tablespoons white balsamic vinegar
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • 1 tablespoon water or vegetable broth (if you have extra lying around)
  • 1 tablespoon extra virgin olive oil (optional)
  • 1 teaspoon prepared mustard
  • 1 teaspoon chopped shallot
  • 1/2 teaspoon maple syrup
  • 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt


  • Add all ingredients to a blender, and blend until perfectly smooth. Use immediately and refrigerate any extra (makes about 1 cup - a serving is 2 tablespoons).


*What do a I mean by "shallowly cored"? Instead of digging deep into the tomato to core it, just remove a shallow v-shaped slice of the hard stem end. It's not necessary to do this for cherry tomatoes, by the way.


Calories: 31kcal
Nutritional information, if shown, is provided as a courtesy only, and is not to be taken as medical information or advice. The nutritional values of your preparation of this recipe are impacted by several factors, including, but not limited to, the ingredient brands you use, any substitutions or measurement changes you make, and measuring accuracy.

Pin Tomato Lover’s Tomato Salad recipe for later:

Pinterest fans, if you’d like to save this recipe for later, use these images (or any image above) to pin to your boards (they’re small here, but thanks to the magic of the interwebs, they’ll be full size when you pin them). Thanks for sharing, and most of all, thank you so much for reading this post! Blogging wouldn’t be any fun without you!

Tomato Lover's Tomato Salad with Smoky Tomato Dressing - Recipe at SoupAddict.com | vegetarianTomato Lover's Tomato Salad with Smoky Tomato Dressing - Recipe at SoupAddict.com | vegetarian

Recipe Rating

Rebekah Ryan

Tuesday 26th of October 2021

So we made this wonderfully tasty dressing... in fact we doubled it! There were 5 of us having it on our salad. We all loved the flavor. I only had one issue though. It was really thin. We like a little more creamy when it comes to dressings. Any suggestions? Thanks! ?

Elizabeth @ Bowl of Delicious

Tuesday 8th of August 2017

Just harvested a ton of tomatoes from my garden- I need to try this!

Melissa Griffiths

Monday 7th of August 2017

Homemade dressing is totally where it's at! I can't wait for my tomatoes to actually produce so I can do all the tomato things!


Monday 7th of August 2017

It's definitely been a crazy tomato summer. My plants have tons of fruit, but they're slow to ripen. Maddening, for sure!


Monday 7th of August 2017

Loooooooove Tomatoes!! This is another keeper for sure~


Monday 7th of August 2017

Tomatoes FTW! :D